INTRODUCTION
Paraneoplastic encephalitis is a neurologic manifestation of paraneoplastic syndrome that can present as seizure, memory impairment, cognitive decline, behavior changes, gait disturbance, and/or psychiatric symptoms [
1]. Classically, paraneoplastic encephalitis has been defined as the presence or high risk of cancer accompanied by certain neurologic symptoms including limbic encephalitis, encephalomyelitis, subacute cerebellar degeneration, and subacute sensory neuropathy, without any other causes [
2]. Recent studies have found various autoantibodies associated with tumors [
3]. Certain types of tumors, such as small-cell lung carcinoma and thymoma, are more likely to develop into paraneoplastic encephalitis. However, there are few reports that paraneoplastic encephalitis can occur in other cancers [
4-
7]. In such cases, paraneoplastic encephalitis is severe enough to complicate medical decisions.
Renal cell carcinoma (RCC) is cancer developed from renal cells of several different types according to the cellular origin [
8]. Clear cell is the most common type of RCC, though few case reports of paraneoplastic encephalitis associated with clear cell RCC have been published [
9-
11]. All aforementioned cases presented with limbic encephalitis, showing memory impairment and cognitive decline without clear lesion on brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). However, a limited number of case studies fully characterized the clinical phenotype and outcomes of paraneoplastic encephalitis associated with RCC.
Here, we identified three patients who had autoimmune encephalitis accompanied by RCC and reported the clinical characteristics, treatments, and outcomes.
METHODS
We enrolled patients with encephalitis accompanied by RCC from our prospective cohort of autoimmune encephalitis between September 2019 and February 2021. The patients who fulfilled the following criteria were included as paraneoplastic encephalitis associated with RCC: (1) possible autoimmune encephalitis according to the operational autoimmune encephalitis diagnostic criteria [
1] and (2) RCC simultaneous diagnosis with neurological manifestation of encephalitis. We confirm that we have read the Journal’s position on issues involved in ethical publication and affirm that this report is consistent with those guidelines. This study was approved by the Seoul National University Hospital Institutional Review Board (1705-130-856). We received written informed consent from all patients and/or legal guardians.
We performed a diagnostic approach following specific guidelines of the Korean Epilepsy Society for patients with unknown encephalitis and epilepsy type [
12]. Laboratory examinations included tests for viral polymerase chain reaction (PCR), tuberculosis PCR, bacterial and fungal microbial culture, neurosarcoidosis, and neuro-Behçet. We screened for autoantibodies including
N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor, leucine-rich glioma-inactivated 1, aquaporin 4, myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein, myelin-associated glycoprotein, contactin-associated protein-like 2, anti-α-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionic acid 1, AMPA2, and γ-aminobutyric-acid type B receptors, Hu, Yo, Ri, Ma2, CV2/CRMP5, amphiphysin, recoverin, Sox1, and Titin (Euroimmun AG, Lubeck, Germany). Cancer screening was performed with low-dose chest computed tomography (CT), abdominal and pelvic CT, and stool hemoglobin. Mammography and breast sonography were performed additionally in female patients.
Empirical immunotherapy was administrated as soon as possible if autoimmune etiology was suspected. Based on cancer stage, patients were assigned to radical or partial nephrectomy as the primary treatment for RCC. Clinical outcomes were assessed with the Clinical Scale in Autoimmune Encephalitis (CASE) [
13] and modified Rankin scale (mRS).
RESULTS
Characteristics and treatment outcome of patients
Among 558 patients who were enrolled in our prospective cohort, three presented with autoimmune encephalitis and RCC (
Table 1). All showed limbic encephalitis, presenting with altered mentality, memory impairment, or seizure. Two patients (patient 1 and 2) had clear cell RCC, and one patient (patient 3) had chromophobe RCC. The cancer was detected before neurological manifestation in two patients (patient 1 and 3); in patient 2, the RCC was found during malignancy workup for autoimmune encephalitis. For the autoantibody test, two patients (patient 1 and 3) showed nonspecific antibodies such as microsome antibody and antinuclear antibody (ANA); however, none had classic paraneoplastic autoantibodies such as anti-Hu, Yo, Ri, Ma2, CV2/CRMP5, amphiphysin, recoverin, Sox1, or Titin. In brain MRI, patients with clear cell RCC (patient 1 and 2) showed T2 hypersignal intensities (HSI) involving the mesial temporal lobe, and the patient with chromophobe RCC (patient 3) had no remarkable findings. All patients received immunotherapy and nephrectomy. Two patients (patient 1 and 3) underwent radical nephrectomy, and one (patient 2) had partial nephrectomy. However, only one patient (patient 1) had early surgery within one month of onset of neurological symptoms. While patient 1 had a favorable response to the treatment, patient 2 had a partial response with sequelae, and patient 3 showed poor results without clear improvement. The clinical histories of the three patients are described below.
Case 1 (patient 1)
A 54-year-old female was referred to our hospital due to altered mental state and memory impairment. One month before neurologic manifestation, she underwent cancer screening due to progressive body weight loss (9 kg over 2 years), and a 2.0-cm-sized right upper kidney mass was detected by abdominal CT (
Figure 1A). While waiting for admission for surgery, the patient presented fever, confusion, and global amnesia. She received empiric antibiotic and antiviral treatment under diagnosis of infectious meningoencephalitis at a local hospital, but the global amnesia aggravated over the next 3 weeks. At an examination in our hospital, her orientation and memory were impaired, showing a Mini-Mental Status Exam score of 20, CASE of 5, and mRS of 4. A cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) test was within the normal range (white blood cells [WBCs], 2/μL [monocyte 50%, lymphocyte 50%]; protein, 49 mg/dL; glucose ratio, 99/168), and the immunoglobulin G (IgG) index was at the upper normal limit at 0.57. Brain MRI revealed symmetric T2 HSI involving both hippocampi (
Figure 1A). Through an extensive examination covering infection and autoantibody-mediated disease, the patient tested positive only for microsome antibodies. Therefore, we concluded that the encephalitis was paraneoplastic encephalitis associated with RCC. After immunotherapy with high-dose corticosteroid (methylprednisolone at 1,000 mg intravenously for 5 days) and intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) (0.4 g/kg/day for 5 days), she underwent a right-side radical open nephrectomy at day 30 from onset of neurological symptoms. The RCC was clear cell type, and the stage was T1aN0M0 with World Health Organization (WHO) grade II (
Figure 1A). During the 1-year follow-up, her mental status and memory fully recovered without recurrence.
Case 2 (patient 2)
A 51-year-old male was admitted because of a mid-age newly-onset seizure. He was previously healthy and had no recent history of travel or vaccination. At 4 days before admission, he experienced autonomous pilomotor movement on the left side of his body for 1 minute. On the day of admission, a focal seizure originated from the left side of his facial muscles and spread to the left arm and leg. The seizure propagated into a generalized tonic seizure of 1 minute. On neurologic examination, he was drowsy and disoriented, showing CASE of 4 and mRS of 4. Brain MRI revealed multifocal T2 HSI in the right temporal lobe, thalamus, and bilateral medial frontal lobes, with sulcal enhancement in the right frontal lobe (
Figure 1B). The CSF test was normal (WBC, 0/μL; protein, 24 mg/dL; glucose ratio, 59/101), but the IgG index was high at 0.79. Electroencephalogram (EEG) recordings revealed a focal seizure disorder originating from the right fronto-temporoparietal area. Repetitive laboratory tests for infection were all negative, and no autoantibodies were found. However, on malignancy screenings, a 2.5-cm-sized heterogeneously enhancing mass was detected in the upper pole of the right kidney (
Figure 1B). In suspicion of paraneoplastic encephalitis associated with RCC, immunotherapy with high-dose corticosteroid (methylprednisolone at 1,000 mg intravenously for 5 days), IVIg (0.4 g/kg/day for 5 days), and rituximab (375 mg/m
2 for one cycle) was administered to the patient within 1 week from seizure onset. On day 49 from the seizure, partial nephrectomy was performed. The RCC was clear cell type of stage T1aN0MO, and WHO grade was III. After treatment, the EEG data were normal, and the follow-up brain MRI revealed decreased extent of T2 hyperintensities at the right hemisphere, but the subcortical lesion remained at the right temporal lobe (
Figure 1B). A focal-aware seizure presenting as metamorphopsia and olfactory hallucination remained as sequelae with CASE of 2 and mRS of 3.
Case 3 (patient 3)
A 54-year-old female was transferred to our hospital because of memory impairment, aphasia, and psychosis. Since 2 months before admission to our hospital, she gained bodyweight of 13 kg with generalized edema. The patient was admitted to a local hospital, and on abdominal CT, a 3.7-cm-sized exophytic mass was found in the upper pole of the left kidney (
Figure 1C). During a further workup, transient right facial palsy and right-side weakness occurred for two hours, but brain MRI and EEG could not find any specific lesion (
Figure 1C). Since 2 days before transfer to our hospital, her sleep cycle and memory were impaired suddenly, and the patient experienced visual hallucination. Indicated by neurologic exam on the transfer day, she was severely disoriented and had sensory aphasia, unable to understand the doctor’s direction, showing a CASE of 9. Repeat brain MRI was normal, and a large number of theta to delta waves was seen on EEG of the bilateral hemispheres. The CSF study showed mild pleocytosis with elevated protein (WBC, 12/μL [monocyte 33%, lymphocyte 33%]; protein, 193 mg/dL; glucose ratio, 83/140). No evidence of infectious origin was found through extensive laboratory tests, but repetitive autoimmune antibody test showed weak positivity for ANA (1:40) and increased serum IgG (1,727). Therefore, an autoimmune etiology was suspected, for IVIg (0.4 g/kg/day for 5 days) was administered to the patient at 3 weeks after transient right-sided facial palsy and weakness. The patient responded to the immunotherapy, recovering mRS from 4 to 1 and lowering CASE to 3. A radical nephrectomy with
en bloc adrenalectomy was performed on day 48 from onset of the neurological manifestation, and the RCC was chromophobe type of stage T1aN0M0 and WHO grade III (
Figure 1C). However, since the first 5 days after surgery, her mental status rapidly aggravated to stupor. Despite additional immunotherapy of IVIg and rituximab, the patient remained unresponsive and passed away on day 67 from onset because of multiple complications of acute renal failure and septic shock.
DISCUSSION
In this case series, we reported three patients with encephalitis accompanied by RCC. The encephalitis manifested as limbic encephalitis in all patients. Two patients with clear cell RCC had favorable outcomes of combined immunotherapy and nephrectomy, while one patient with chromophobe RCC showed a transient response but eventually a detrimental outcome. These cases suggest that RCC can present as paraneoplastic encephalitis and be responsive to immunotherapy but can have complications throughout the course of treatment.
Our patients’ encephalitis accompanied by RCC could be considered paraneoplastic encephalitis. According to the former diagnostic criteria, limbic encephalitis, which our patients manifested, is a classical paraneoplastic encephalitis syndrome of the central nervous system, and our cases are consistent with the category of definite paraneoplastic encephalitis regardless of presence of onconeuronal antibodies [
2]. Moreover, the recent diagnostic criteria for autoimmune encephalitis were met in all patients [
1], corresponding with the definition of paraneoplastic encephalitis as autoimmune encephalitis in which immune cells sensitize a self-antigen of the nervous system in a tumor microenvironment. Therefore, immunotherapy combined with tumor resection could have been effective in our patients.
For patient 3, paraneoplastic encephalitis was accompanied by chromophobe RCC but not by clear cell RCC. To date, the cancer type paraneoplastic encephalitis associated with RCC was clear cell (
Table 2). RCC is represented by a collection of heterogeneous histology, and clear cell RCC is the most common type, which originates from atypical neoplasm of a proximal convoluted tubule epithelium. Chromophobe RCC is differentiated histologically and molecularly from clear cell RCC in that it originates from the distal convoluted tubule epithelium [
8,
14,
15]. Therefore, the pathomechanism of paraneoplastic encephalitis might be different according to origin of RCC. However, we could not find any definite autoantibodies, and patient 3 had a grave outcome after surgery. In turn, neurologic manifestation of chromophobe RCC requires further investigation.
Our case series is a small study of only three patients, but it is meaningful in that we treated them according to certain guidelines in a single tertiary institution [
12]. Although paraneoplastic encephalitis with RCC is a rare condition, clinicians should be aware of it and apply immunotherapy as soon as possible because the encephalitis could remain a permanent sequela. As our cases showed that paraneoplastic encephalitis with RCC could present as limbic encephalitis, malignancy screening for RCC is recommended in patients with seronegative autoimmune encephalitis.